|
Installation
From here on in anybody reading this review should
have less trouble than myself while installing a SLK-800U.
Removal of the motherboard from its case in this
situation is unfortunately mandatory. Place the clear
plastic sheet on top of the x-shaped motherboard mounting
panel and place the motherboard on top of this. I
took no chances and placed four washers directly between
the mounting panel and the motherboard. There is a
high chance that without these washers the motherboard
would be short circuited by the panel, which to those
who haven't already realized, is bad news.

Line up mounting holes with mounting holes, and grab
a fake standoff. These special standoffs have extra-long
male ends, the upper half without threads. Insert
the male end through another clear motherboard washer,
and place this end through the motherboard mounting
holes into the mounting panel. Turn counter-clockwise
until a small amount of slack is still present but
stop before any one becomes too tight. Turn the motherboard
on its edge and make sure no corners are too close
to the motherboard and that some are not: excessive
pressure from the panel on the mainboard is not a
good thing. The next logical step would be to remove
the base cover, apply your favourite thermal compound
to both the CPU and heatsink, and plop it on top.
This is NOT the next step in the installation phase.
Thermalright's heatsink is too narrow to rely on the
supplied heatsink cushions provided on AMD's CPU cores,
so one should apply the 3M pads to the four dimples
on the heatsink. Now you may return to thermal pasting
and lining up the heatsink with the fake standoffs.
Now place the metal washers on top of the black piece
of metal encircling the SLK-800U, overtop the holes
lining up with the standoffs. Install spring screws
into standoffs, and your heatsink is installed. Now,
choose your fan, place fan mounting clips into the
appropriate holes with the clip facing towards the
inside of the fan, place fan on heatsink, and pull
the clips overtop into the mounting holes. You're
set!
Test Rig
After all this hard work, we get to have a little
fun.
Here's the related machine specs on which the SLK-800U
was tested with:
AMD AthlonXP 2100+ Palomino
Abit KX7-333 (note: the KX7-333 is equipped with a
CPU thermal diode longer than usual, which touches
the underside of the processor and detects hotter
than average temperatures, yet are still lower than
the actual die temperature readings)
Thermaltake Xaser II A5000B case
ToCools Novasonic
80x25mm Delta fan which was used on both heatsinks,
pushing 44cfm at 40dB/a
Nanotherm Silver thermal compound
Results
Ambient temperatures were measured by Thermaltake's
Hardcano 7 Temperature sensor. CPU load temperatures
were achieved with the assistance of Folding@home,
and then in case that wasn't enough already, by running
HotCPU Testor for 10 minutes. Temperatures were stable
in all areas.

Conclusion
The 3DVelocity 'Dual Conclusions Concept' Explained:
After discussing this concept with users as well as
companies and vendors we work with, 3DVelocity have
decided that where necessary we shall aim to introduce
our 'Dual Conclusions Concept' to sum up our thoughts
and impressions on the hardware we review. As the
needs of the more experienced users and enthusiasts
have increased, it has become more difficult to factor
in all the aspects that such a user would find important,
while also being fair to products that may lack these
high end "bonus" capabilities but which
still represent a very good buy for the more traditional
and more prevalent mainstream user. The two catergories
we've used are:
The Mainstream User ~ The mainstream user
is likely to put price, stock performance, value for
money, reliability and/or warranty terms ahead of
the need for hardware that operates beyond its design
specifications. The mainstream user may be a PC novice
or may be an experienced user, however their needs
are clearly very different to those of the enthusiast,
in that they want to buy products that operate efficiently
and reliably within their advertised parameters.
The Enthusiast ~ The enthusiast cares about
all the things that the mainstream user cares about
but is more likely to accept a weakness in one or
more of these things in exchange for some measure
of performance or functionality beyond its design
brief. For example, a high priced motherboard may
be tolerated in exchange for unusually high levels
of overclocking ability or alternatively an unusually
large heat sink with a very poor fixing mechanism
may be considered acceptable if it offers significantly
superior cooling in return.
Mainstream User:
While $43 isn't a lot of money, there are always
cheaper alternatives such as CoughStockCoughHeatsinksCough
which would yield the same important results: the
computer turns on! While a very small percentage of
computers are ever overclocked and heat is not usually
an issue on out-of-the-box PCs I would have to say
this heatsink is overkill. Considering installation
requires the removal of the motherboard which is a
bit of a PITA try and remember how most mainstream
users do not know how to install a motherboard properly.
On the bright side, it is very securely fastened after
installation and probably poses less of a threat to
your hardware than a stock heatsink clamping onto
those socket lugs. Lacking a fan and instructions
makes this just slightly less appealing to someone
who either doesn't know what they're doing, or simply
can't be bothered to buy a proper fan.

Enthusiast:
As far as cooling capacity goes, this heatsink sure
pulls its weight. It beat out my previous heatsink,
the ToCools Novasonic, by three degrees Celsius with
a handicap of 1C ambient. While we're still over 40C,
remember the ABIT thermal sensor actually touches
the CPU and this happens to be a stock palomino so
those ratings are nothing to scoff at! Apart from
being an incomplete CPU cooler, requiring difficult
installation procedures (we sure took care of that!)
and lacking instructions, I have found nothing to
complain about regarding this heatsink. Its design
is tight and strong. It performs well above the competition.
It includes mounting hardware for many sizes of fans.
It fits both AMD and Intel CPUs. It is very securely
mounted on the motherboard and poses a minimal threat
to going the way of standard CPU lug-mounted heatsinks
imitating a brick in the event of a dropped case.
At $43 you're getting a great deal as you probably
get better performance out of this than your average
$120 watercooling setup! If you're serious about cooling
air-cooling does you fine the SLK-800-U is your best
buy.

Be sure to pick up a Thermalright SLK-800-U
from Newegg at
$42.99!

|